Replacing or repairing your roof is a major financial decision. If you're wondering how to find a good roofer, how to pick a roofer, or how to select a roofer you can trust, asking the right questions upfront will protect you from poor workmanship, surprise costs, and fly-by-night operators.

Whether you need a full architectural shingle replacement or a complex leak fix, learning how to hire a roofer and how to find a reputable roofer starts with this definitive checklist of questions to ask a roofer before hiring in New Jersey.


1. Are you licensed as a Home Improvement Contractor in New Jersey?

New Jersey law mandates that every residential roofing contractor register with the NJ Division of Consumer Affairs. Always ask for their active NJ HIC license number (e.g., Bridgewater Roofer holds Lic #13VH09876500) and verify it online before signing anything.

2. Do you carry both General Liability and Workers' Compensation insurance?

Never hire an uninsured roofer. A reputable contractor carries at least $2,000,000 in General Liability insurance to protect your home and property, plus comprehensive Workers' Compensation to cover their crew on your roof. Always request a Certificate of Insurance (COI) sent directly from their insurance agency.

3. Are you factory-certified by major shingle manufacturers?

Top manufacturers like GAF and CertainTeed reserve their elite certifications (such as GAF Master Elite or CertainTeed Master Craftsman) for the top 2% of roofers. Factory certification qualifies you for 50-year non-prorated system warranties backed directly by the manufacturer.

4. Will you pull the required municipal building permits?

Under the New Jersey Uniform Construction Code (UCC), roof replacements require a municipal permit from your township code enforcement office. A reputable roofer will pull all necessary permits, file engineering specs, and coordinate the final township inspection. If a roofer asks you to pull the permit yourself, that is a major red flag!

5. Do you tear off the old roof down to the plywood decking?

While some low-cost contractors offer to nail new shingles over old layers ("overlay"), this traps trapped moisture and conceals rotten plywood. A professional contractor always strips the roof down to the bare wood to inspect decking, replace rotted boards, and install fresh ice-and-water barriers.

6. What ice-and-water protection and underlayment do you install?

New Jersey winters bring ice dams and freeze-thaw cycles. Ensure your contractor installs self-adhering ice-and-water shield membranes at least 24 inches past the interior wall line, along all valleys, and around chimney flashings, paired with breathable synthetic underlayment.

7. What warranties do you offer on materials and workmanship?

There are two distinct warranties: the manufacturer warranty (covering defective materials) and the contractor workmanship warranty (covering installation labor and leak prevention). Look for written workmanship warranties of 10 to 25 years.

8. How will you protect my property, driveway, and landscaping?

A full roof replacement generates thousands of pounds of old shingles and nails. Ask if they use specialized heavy tarps, plywood shields for AC units, and perform multiple passes with rolling magnetic sweepers to collect stray roofing nails.

9. Who will be managing the project on-site daily?

Ask whether a dedicated project manager or crew foreman will be on-site throughout the installation to answer your questions and perform quality control audits at each phase.

10. Do you provide a detailed, written itemized estimate?

Avoid vague one-page handwritten quotes. Your written estimate should clearly specify shingle brands, drip edge metal, ridge ventilation, underlayment type, dumpster disposal, permit fees, and payment schedule.

Need Straightforward Advice from a Local NJ Roofer?

Bridgewater Roofer provides 100% free, written roof inspections and estimates across Somerset County with zero sales pressure.

Call for Free Estimate: (908) 465-9944
Tap to Call Roofer Direct (908) 465-9944
24/7 Live